Tuesday, June 12, 2007

Letter to the English Churchman on Canon Law, and Sacramental & Liturgical Theology



Dear Sir
Re: Deposited Prayer-Book (1927) and all that ...

I would like to follow up on the front page article of EC 7628, and David Relf's letter (EC 7629) concerning canon law, the Gorham case and the Deposited Prayer-Book respectively.

Firstly, the See of Rome does not recognise the canon law of the Church of England and - alongside with it - the episcopal credentials of its 'apostolic succession' (e.g. Apostolicae Curae, 1897) precisely because of the break of communion between the two. However, the Reformed English Church inherited her pre-Reformation canon law substantially intact with significant modification (i.e. the procedural discipline and material corpus are now grounded in royal authority, and indirectly, Parliament's legislation for their enforcement, e.g. through the Act of Uniformity, 1559).

Secondly, the Gorham decision at the Privy Council demonstrated that the appellant (i.e. Rev. George Cornelius Gorham) agreed with the Bp. of Exeter (i.e. Henry Philpotts) as to the 'ordinary connection' between the grace of the Holy Spirit and the Sacrament of Baptism (cf. Article 25). They also shared a common notion of Regeneration (as instantaneous/an event which excludes a priori experience and eludes subjective description).

Where they differed was to the timing of Regeneration, i.e. whether 'ORIGINAL' prevenient grace was bound to Baptism or not in respect of infants. The answer depended on the role of Baptism and, by extension, the scope of baptismal efficacy which - the old-fashioned High Churchman (albeit POST-1662/Arminian) - Philpotts construed as applying ex opere operato (i.e. invariably) though without the concomitance of 'renovation' (i.e. inner change) or 'conversion' (the mutual inclusiveness of both is held by Roman, Tractarian and Calvinist alike), which means Baptismal Regeneration, according to this theory (also held by the first two traditions) is informed by ecclesiastical election ('monergistic') but 'final salvation' is based on God's foreknowledge of who will persevere to the end('synergistic'). Only Calvinists like Gorham limited Regeneration in Baptism (if it occurs during the administration of the rite) to elect infants only because the order of salvation (ordo salutis) is grounded in sovereign predestination, thus, making the entire 'chain of salvation' (in ordinary LOGICAL, as distinguished from temporal, sequence) inseparable: Election, Regeneration, Calling, Conversion (Definitive Sanctification), Faith (& Repentance), Baptism, Justification, Sanctification/Conversion, Glorification.

Thirdly, the Deposited Prayer-Book (1927) attempted to redress Roman proclivities on ecumenical and devotional issues within a liturgical context. Thus, the aim was to maintain so-called Anglican comprehensiveness whilst supressing illegal practices through pastoral methods within the Prayer-Book tradition. It included prominently the formulation of an alternative Eucharistic (Consecration) Prayer ('a Canon within Canon') drafted by scholars like Walter Howard Frere (Bp. of Truro) who looked to the 'East' (both early and Byzantine), the 1549 'Invocation' and subsequent 'epicleses' (e.g. 1637, 1764) - of the 'greater Anglican tradition' of which the Caroline divines were the best representatives in the terms of the catholic heritage of the Church - for inspiration and resources.

It was conceived as a liturgical measure (backed by ecclesiastical sanction) partly to rein in on popular abuses associated either with 'Transubstantiation' or a locaLISED (not 'local') presence - and the concomitant theory of the propitiatory Sacrifice of the Mass - according to extreme Anglo-Catholic gloss of the Words of Institution (WOI: Narrative component) in 1662 Office.

Perhaps a possible strategy by classical Anglicans (i.e. Prayer-Book evangelicals) in 1927 to counter 'Anglo-Catholic influence was to reclaim the liturgical inheritance of the Caroline divines or PRE-1662 Laudians, i.e. Reformation High-Church Protestants (the majority of which, with the exception Jeremy Taylor, held to single predestination and forensic justification, including the venerable Abps. William Laud and Richard Neile of York) who with the moderate Puritan divines shared a common concern for the inclusion of an explicit Invocation and restoration of manual acts in conjunction with the WOI (the latter of which was to be incorporated at the Savoy Conference, 1661). The liturgical divergence was in the treatment of the WOI, i.e. whether set within the context of a prayer (which the Prayer-Book tradition undeniably places it) or in a mono-didactic role (as in Continental Reformed and Presbyterian traditions).

The notion of an epiclesis alongside the WOI gives full expression to the intent of the Church to commemorate the Lord's Supper in the words and action of the liturgy. God the Father is invoked to send down His Spirit to 'bless (or approve) and sanctify (or set apart) these gifts of bread and wine' in hypostatic union and conjunction with the (written) Word 'so that these may be unto us (by faith) the Body and Blood of Christ'. This is where the sanctification of the species/elements and people is concentrated at the point immediately prior to reception.

Implicit in this invocation is the Eucharist primarily as a divine action in which the human response (i.e. gratitude) is set within the 'use' (presentation/oblation-prayer/invocation sequence and communion/reception) of the sacramental species which includes a 'pleading' - by the COMMON priesthood - of the merits of the 'one oblation of Christ finished upon the Cross', as per Article 31 through locating the post-communion offertory of praise and thanksgiving (sacrificium laudis) after the Invocation/epiclesis. This is distinguished sharply from the mainstream Anglo-Catholic 'co-offering' with Christ of His perpetual heavenly sacrifice.

Whether the placement of the 'epiclesis' is before or after the WOI and Oblation/anamnesis is insignificant if 'Calvinistic' sacramental theology of the Real Presence (both Calvin's and Cranmer's Virtualism) as representing the best of mature Anglican reflection in the Eucharist is again asserted in its rightful place in the Communion Office 'configurated' by the supplemental components of Sursum Corda, Sanctus, Prayer of Humble Access, Lord's Prayer, Gloria in exclesis Deo, etc. Note too that Westminster Puritanism in its 1645 Directory for Public Worship contains a similar invocation (last paragraph of the prayer), albeit outside the perimeters of its Narrative component.

Lastly, however, I am bound my reverence to our Protestant forefathers, including the then Conservative MP, William Joynson-Hicks (later Lord Brentford) and its authentic contemporary embodiment in the Church of England (Continuing) to 'reject' the Deposited Prayer-Book (1927) as an alternative to the BCP (1662).

Labels: , ,

Sunday, June 10, 2007

Coming Up Next ...


Triadology ...

  • Augustinian Filioquism and Byzantine Monarchianism - A Synthesis in the Ordo Theologiae?
Christology ...
  • Hypostatic Union and Imputation
  • Christ's sinlessness and Original Sin

Soteriology ...

  • The salvific will of God
  • Eucharist, Justification and Sanctification

Labels: , , , , , , ,

Wednesday, June 06, 2007

Unpublished Letter to the English Churchman on Divorce and Remarriage


"What God hath joined together, let not man put asunder' ...

Dear Sir,
Re: Divorce and Remarriage in Holy Scripture and Tradition

This letter is not a condemnation of those who differ from the views of Mr. J. F. Burrows on divorce and remarriage but a humble and sincere plea that the Word of God on the issue be considered afresh.

The teaching of the Early (i.e. the first four centuries, incl. Eastern) and Medieval (i.e. pre-Reformation) Western Church are reflected in the consensus patri (viz. Church fathers) whereby marriage was regarded as an unbreakable or indissoluble bond (vinculum) which was broken or dissolved only upon the death of one spouse. The Early Church was virtually unanimous on this issue (with very few exceptions, contrary to the Catholic understanding of the teaching of Christ as handed down by the Apostles).

The Church of England maintained the 'indissolubist' view of marriage which was enshrined in canon 107 (The Constitution and Canons Ecclesiastical, 1603) and in that respect differed from the continental Reformed Churches and the majority of the Protestant Reformers; and legal separation a thoro et mensa (i.e. a 'divorce' NOT amounting to a right to remarry) remained its OFFICIAL position until only recently (i.e. 1970s). In response to Mr. Alan Bartley: Cases of nobility and the wealthy seeking full divorce (which is usually brought about by an Act of Parliament, e.g. the Lord Ross case, 1669) and opinions expressed by the laity do not alter that fact. Also, the apostate Roman Church did not depart from the Catholic view but reaffirmed it at the Council of Trent (1563), canon VII (24th session).

I would urge that the classical evangelical exegesis of Matthew 19 (i.e. the Christic as opposed to the rabbinical exposition) be re-examined. It is clear that DIVORCE (i.e. putting away) is only permitted on grounds of adultery (i.e. sexual sin on the part of the guilty spouse) in response to the Pharisaical (trap) question; and Christ immediately adds - in typical proleptic and terse manner in verse 9 - that REMARRIAGE on the part of the innocent spouse constitutes adultery and not just the person who marries the guilty spouse who has been divorced! The force of logic implicit in the 'exception clause' (of Matt. 19:9) is that the marriage bond is still intact. Cf. Matthew 5:32, Mark 10:11-12, Luke 16:18, Romans 7:2-3, 1 Corinthians 7:39 on the absolute prohibition of REMARRIAGE during the lifetime of the other spouse.

For Christians, marriage is mirrored in the love of Christ (the divine Bridegroom) for the Church, His Bride (Ephesians 5:23-33) which is ultimately grounded in the intra-Trinitarian relations of the Being of God (i.e. the perichoresis or mutual indwelling between Father and Son with the Holy Spirit as the vinculum amoris, i.e. BOND of love as the 'archetypal' Covenant relationship.

Labels: , , ,

Letter to the English Churchman on Lent (Part 2)


Dear Sir,
Re: Lent and the Regulative Principle of Worship

It is unfair of Mr. Cyril Blackstock to smear the Anglican observance of Lent with the celebration of the Mardi Gras carnival associated with ordinary Roman Catholics. Such abuses at the grass-roots level does not represent the official teaching of the Roman Church albeit tolerated, as with other common errors, by the hierarchy alongside other absurdities (e.g. the case of the Marian apparition appearing on a pancake after recital of the Novena by a rosary practitioner on Shrove Tuesday). However, even the Bishops Conference of Yugoslavia was consistent in its extreme caution about Marian apparitions in Medjugorje and the Vatican has issued a public ban on pilgrimages to some supposed sites and shrines (Notification by the Sacred Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, 1974).

Nonetheless, for the Protestant to insist for a scriptural imperative for every practice by the Church - divorced from its environment - is unwarranted by the Bible itself and Church history (see Romans 14 on feast days and diet, 1 Corinthians 11 on the essential shape of the Eucharistic Liturgy --- common or individual cups? leavened or unleavened bread?, chap. 14 on the principles of worship --- instrumental accompaniment?, Acts 2 about meeting places for worship and frequency of communion --- church buildings?, chap. 6 with respect to the first ordering of deacons, chap. 12 about allusion to Jewish feast days in the apostolic church etc.). In these instances, there were no specific divine mandate regulating or forbidding non-essential/accidental customs but that they were either grounded on earlier precedents or arose out of the exigency of circumstances.

In fact, such insistence is analogous to the Roman’s & Byzantine’s demand e.g. that their peculiar formulation of the Quam oblationem and Epiklesis respectively is an integral prayer or petition/invocation in the Canon of the Mass or Liturgy that complements the Words of Institution either before its recitation by a benediction upon the species of bread and wine in preparation for the act of consecration ('Western') or the 'moment' thereof (after the Anaphora, i.e. Offering) when they are released back to the Church to be “manifested” as the Antitypes of the Body and Blood of Christ (Eastern). ('Transubstantiation' and elevation are condemned in Article 28).

Lent pre-dates the rise of the papacy and is independent of any pagan connotation. Rather, it is the so-called Orange Orders (both the Established and Independent) that are imbued with pagan rituals and Freemasonry. They are also linked by cross-membership with other esoteric societies that are in continuity with medieval secular orders whose original mission was not propagation of the Gospel but to advance the temporal ambitions of the Roman Church. These associations represent the survival of Gnostic heresies and triumph of occult circles in Christendom.

In contrast, Lenten fasting is rooted in Scripture and the example of Christ. The use of ashes from burned palm branches prominent from the 7th century onwards and adopted into the Medieval Church are legalistic mimicries of Old Testament symbolisms; nowhere to be found or sanctioned in the Prayer book and the authentic Anglican tradition (cf. 'Concerning Ceremonies', after the 'Preface' to the Book of Common Prayer).

The fervency with which classical Anglicans and successors of the Puritan separatists (i.e. pre- & post-1662) disagree on the Regulative Principle of Worship should not mean that one side should attempt to 'impose' their local tradition on the other nor should it detract from the broad liturgical spectrum that historically existed within classical Protestantism, viz. Reformed Orthodoxy and confessional Lutheranism, thus reflecting the catholicity of the Reformation Churches.

And despite internal diversity on some doctrinal issues also, there is a common and unified front over-against Rome and Constantinople (both the Chalcedon Patriarchates and the “non-canonical” Assyrian/Nestorian and Coptic/Monophysite Churches). Not only have these churches erred but grievously so on the issue of justification by faith alone resting upon the twin pillars of the total depravity of man and the absolute sovereignty of God.

May the true Church of Christ in this realm continue to guard the deposit of truth and contend against all errors supported by genuine Protestant societies in the propagation of Reformation principles, promotion of the Reformed Faith and defence of the British Constitution.

Labels: , ,

Letter to the English Churchman on Lent (Part 1)


Dear Sir,
Re: Lent

We appreciate the remarks made by Mr. Cyril Blackstock about the origins of the (penitential season of) Lent. However, its history predates the rise of the papacy and is rooted in the observance of Easter/Paschal Sunday by the early Christian communities, i.e. the 'Lencten' (Anglo-Saxon for 'spring'; the Latin equivalent: 'quadragesima' and Greek: 'tessarokoste' means '40') season was originally an expansion of the pre-vigil fasting discipline prior to the celebration of the Resurrection of Christ on Sunday which eventually became the prevalent practice in the Catholic Church in contrast to the 14th Nisan/Jewish Passover/Paschal following the Babylonian lunar calendar of the Asia Minor churches. This is significant for it represents the mature understanding of the early Church concerning the fulfilment of Old Testament prototypes by New Testament antitypes. The 40-day period of fasting or partial abstinence from food became regularised by the time of Nicea (1), 325 A.D which also fixed the 'date' of Easter in the liturgical calendar - representing the triumph of Christian religion over paganism in the Roman Empire - as invariably succeeding the full moon of the vernal equinox of the year.

The imposition of a (system of) penitential-fasting discipline upon the consciences of the faithful – as is the case in the Roman Catholic Church by the Pope (embodying the Magisterium) in e.g. Canon 1251 (Code of Canon Law, 1983) – is not only contrary to Scripture and the primitive Faith but the liturgical tradition of the Church of England (e.g. note the absence of a ritual directive but only the Collects and Scripture readings as ordered according to the Prayer-book). 1 Timothy 4 (note the word, 'command' in verse 3) is to be read in tandem with Romans 14 which deals precisely with the pastoral issues of feast days and diet. Observance of the church calendar stripped of medieval accretions and superstition is an issue of the authority and right by a branch of Christ’s Church to regulate its non-doctrinal customs (ref. Article XXXIV) so long as they are “not repugnant to the Word of God”.

The heresy is observing Lent - a complex of ritual stages - in conjunction with the so-called Sacrament of Penance, and in preparation for Baptism and Confirmation as an integral progress towards our justification before (or a means of obtaining forgiveness from) God through the Church versus the commemoration of (and by extension, participation in) the 'mysteries of salvation' - accomplished once-for-all in the life and ministry of Our Lord 'made present' in these sacred cycles of the church calendar - accompanied by genuine repentance (i.e. 'inward fasting') and prayer in recognition of the free mercy and sovereign grace of God in forgiving sins (see Ash Wednesday Collect). It is the difference between 'grace plus works' and 'grace alone/only' religion. The invocation (i.e. direct impetration) of saints condemned in Article XXII is another perversion whereby prominent saints in Heaven are reduced to departmental deities or secondary mediators. It is these so-called pious practices rampant in modern Anglicanism that represents the reintroduction of paganism in Christendom.

The Church of England (Continuing) - with the exception of the Traditional Protestant Episcopal Church in the American scene – is the only authentic classical Anglican jurisdiction that upholds the Gospel (Ephesians 2:8, 2 Thessalonians 2, 2 Timothy 3, 1 Corinthians 1:21-24, Romans 9 etc.).

Labels: , ,

Sunday, May 27, 2007

Letter to the English Churchman on Theotokos and a Prayer of the Church Militant


Dear Sir,
RE: THE BLESSED VIRGIN MARY AS MOTHER OF GOD

I agree wholeheartedly that the title, “Mother of God (Theotokos)” ascribed by the holy ecumenical council of Ephesus (431 AD) to Our Blessed Virgin Mary has led to many errors (doctrine) and superstitions (practices). Nonetheless, the designation by itself – being the theological reflection of the Church on the essentials of the Faith - is wholly appropriate in expressing the concrete Unity of the Two Natures of Christ in One Person (i.e. the Hypostatic Union), over against the teachings of Nestorius, Patriarch of Constantinople (of the school of Antioch in the tradition of Theodore of Mopsuestia). The “Nestorian” heresy has often been inaccurately described as a Two Person/Sonship Christology. However, both Nestorius and the Nestorians maintained an orthodox understanding of the Incarnation.

The defining issue arose out of the differences over the propriety of interchanging appellations and peculiar properties belonging to one nature with the other (i.e. the communicatio idiomatum). Nonetheless, the occasion for Nestorius’s condemnation was set in the context of ecclesiastical rivalry, instigated in particular by St. Cyril, the great 5th-century defender of Catholic doctrine. The Antiochene school was concerned (see for example, the “Second Epistle of Nestorius to Cyril”) to safeguard the integrity of the Divine Nature and by extension, the Godhead against implications of passibility.

On the Alexandrian side, to deny that sufferings of the Gospel Figure could be referred or transferred to His Divinity weakens the intrinsic oneness - in Identity - of the composite Union and by extension, the impeccability of His Humanity which is absolutely necessary for our redemption. Therefore, Nestorianism amounted to a denial of the complete human experience of Our Lord “for what is not assumed (in the fullest sense) is not saved”, as per the Cappadocian fathers. So, Christ’s Human Nature (including the rational soul or mind) does not subsist apart from the Ego or Self-Consciousness of His Divine Person.

Convinced by that truth, the Orthodox party paid appropriate reverence to the Virgin Mary by addressing her as “Theotokos” (lit. “God-bearer”). This article of faith has always been implicit in the Catholic creeds before Ephesus (431 AD) and the Chalcedonian Definition (451 AD), alongside the lesser status of Mary’s perpetual virginity (“Aeiparthenos”). But, the voice of the broader Ecumenical Church does not condemn, for pastoral reasons, congregations or individuals who refuse to subscribe to this venerable tradition for conscience’s sake, partly because of its association with Mariolatry. The elevation of “Theotokos” as dogma relates only to its Symbolic Representation of the Hypostatic Union and NEVER for its own sake.

Hence, for instance, Luther and his true disciples (i.e. the Gnesio-Lutherans) held to the ubiquity of the God-Man - in relation to His “definitive” presence in the consecrated species – on the basis of “Logos non extra carnem est" (i.e. the Logos is not apart from His flesh). Luther’s phrase that “God died on the Cross” is not Patripassianism precisely because it was not God the Father who was the Subject of the bloody agony and precious death.

Let it be known, that the Church of England (Continuing), alongside the Traditional Protestant Episcopal Church and the Anglican Orthodox Church, in common with the Reformation Churches do utterly denounce the detestable enormities of the Bishop of Rome and confess him as Anti-Christ, and Enemy of the Catholic Faith. We hereby also condemn the false professors of Anglicanism within the Canterbury Communion and the Continuum (for example, the Traditional Anglican Communion – TAC) for their irrefragable movement towards the Man of Sin in fulfilment of the great apostasy of the last days.

“Almighty and ever-living God, Who hast predestined unto glory a Church elected in Christ, we thy unworthy servants, in communion with the Church Triumphant above, continue to beseech Thee for the increase of Thy Holy Spirit in us, that being grounded in the abiding Baptism of Pentecost, assured of the triumphant advance of the Gospel, armed with the Sword of the Spirit, that is, Thy most holy Word and looking for the great and glorious appearing of the Son of Man, our blessed hope: the militant Church here on earth, the pillar and ground of the Truth, would ever contend for the faith once for all delivered unto the saints for the gathering, defence and preservation of the same Catholic Church in all ages; through the one and only Intercession of Our Lord Jesus. Amen”.

Labels: , , , ,